Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 Weasel words and dust - between rock and about-face 

Weasel words and dust - between rock and about-face

MIDNIGHT OIL is getting back together!

The Environment Minister, Peter Garrett, now has the task of selecting a suitably conciliatory song list.

Advance publicity for next month's bushfire benefit gig suggests that headline bands will play "20 minutes of hits".

But can Midnight Oil field 20 whole minutes of material that wouldn't get Mr Garrett sacked if he were to read it out in Parliament rather than shrieking it while twitching violently to guitar music?

Most of the Oils' hits are problematic for one reason or other. US Forces, obviously, is right out. So is Beds Are Burning, albeit for very different and much sadder reasons.

Power And The Passion? With its references to Uncle Sam and Pine Gap? Best left out, on the whole. And as for Truganini - "I see the Union Jack in flames; Let it burn", well - are you kidding? The Dead Heart looks OK for a bit, but disqualifies itself in the final stanza: "Mining companies, pastoral companies, uranium companies. Collected companies; Got more right than people."

This is very off-message stuff here in Ruddland.

One pictures the Environment Minister working his way through the Midnight Oil discography with a despairing red pencil, and eventually opting for a few Veronicas covers. Perhaps the best idea would be to enlist the aid of a guest vocalist, someone who does not feel at all constrained by questions of party loyalty.

How about Tony "People Skills" Abbott? Always wild and unpredictable, People Skills is going through a phase of compulsive truth telling.

Last week he declared Australia couldn't afford to pay pensioners more, and yesterday he made some unkind, if broadly accurate, remarks about the Prime Minister.

"The guy is a toxic bore in the Parliament," he began, in an interview with Sky News, then volunteered that Mr Rudd was "the worst parliamentary performer as Prime Minister since Billy McMahon". A nice touch, with McMahon's widow ill in hospital.

Not much of this will overly trouble Kevin Rudd, who is hovering somewhere between chocolate ice-cream and labrador puppies in the popularity stakes, in a devastating hint that perhaps voters like bores.

To paraphrase Shakespeare: Oh, People Skills, People Skills. Was ever voter in this humour wooed? Was ever voter in this humour won?

We'll leave the last words to the PM himself, who when asked by a reporter whether he was a toxic bore, actually responded thus: "Can I say that anyone, anyone ah, you wrote about this today Matthew, leave that where it is, the um, ah, if you are dealing with the totality of the global economic crisis, unless we have a restoration of private credit markets and private credit flows across the global economy and normal flows within Australia, then we're never dealing with the full dimensions of the problem. That was what I was saying in the Parliament yesterday. That is the reality which every government in the world is wrestling with …(answer edited for reasons of space)."

US FORCES The lyrics to the

Midnight Oil song:

US forces give the nod,

It's a setback for your country,

Bombs and trenches all

in rows,

Bombs and threats still ask

for more,

Divided world the CIA,

Who controls the issue,

You leave us with no time

to talk,

You can write your own assessment,

Sing me songs of no denying,

Seems to me too many trying,

Waiting for the next big thing,

Will you know it when you

see it?

High risk children dogs of war,

Now market movements call the shots,

Business deals in parking lots,

Waiting for the meat of tomorrow,

Everyone is too stoned to

start emission,

People too scared to go

to prison,

We're unable to make decisions,

Political party line don't cross that floor,

L. Ron Hubbard can't save your life,

Superboy takes a plutonium wife,

In the shadows of Ban the Bomb we live.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
We are faced with hypocrisy every day, so what is another concert by a has-been band fronted by the biggest hypocrite to date? Who's keeping score, Krudd?
Posted by Belly, 25/02/2009 1:17:53 PM
The man has deep feelings.
Posted by watcher, 25/02/2009 4:27:11 PM
I think the Oils songs are still appropriate - we are still bowing down to the US when they want more cannon fodder.
Posted by Marilyn, 25/02/2009 4:54:38 PM
Maybe Peter Garrett could employ a string section from the Australian National Academy of Music, the music school he closed down! I hope all those music students have stuck with music. I wish Garrett had too.
Posted by NreeK, 25/02/2009 11:01:43 PM
What can you say about Peter Garret – he’s a sell out. He is a walking contradiction to his former persona as a front man for a band that gave politics the finger and protested against conformity. Yet he is with out doubt the most ineffectual and conformist politician, never really having anything to say except the occasional parroting of party policy. Even Bob Brown who barely moves his lips when speaking exudes more passion for what he believes in. That’s the problem with Garret, his passion is a stage act and the parliament is not his stage.
Posted by chrisc, 26/02/2009 9:33:24 AM
It's just a shame that people can't appreciate the generosity of this gesture. Sure Garret's leaving himself wide open to school-boy style, half witted snide comments from the politically motivated numb-nuts but the fact is that Midnight Oil will succeed in drawing thousands more to the MCG to raise money for a very worthy cause. It's a selfless act that deserves more merit. As for song selection, the Oils can do anything. It's called entertainment. As for politics, I think it's a shame that Garret didn't stand as an independent, after all, anyone could have won a liberal seat at the last election and independents seem to wield a lot more power.
Posted by Circus Maximus, 27/02/2009 12:04:43 AM
Artistic expression should not be gagged by political correctness. As for Garret, a sell out? Please. The man has worn many hats and accomplished much. He decided he could accomplish more by representing the people and he's trying.
Posted by Dannydel, 27/02/2009 7:50:27 AM
Simple Answer - yes Midnight Oil can easily fill a 20 minute set (4, possibly 5 songs) without raising an eyebrow. It wasn't all political protesting, they do have other material. It's just a band singing some songs for CHARITY people - get over yourselves.
Posted by Nobody Home, 27/02/2009 7:43:40 PM
Peter Garrett. Sells out every time.
Posted by Billy G, 27/02/2009 10:10:31 PM
I wonder if Garret, Daniel Johns (Silverchair) and Bono will share another joint or are we supposed to have forgotten about that?
Posted by Aussie Boy, 28/02/2009 9:51:21 AM
1 | 2  |  next >
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!

Most popular articles

 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...